Annie allows Sophie to date an older boy, believing him to positively influence her, but has her suspicions when she finds out he has a secret. Meanwhile, Mackenzie thanks Jack for helping her with schoolwork on the court system by giving him a full-pledged makeover.
Sophie and Mackenzie try out for the cheerleading squad at school but only Sophie lands a spot, leading to friction between their mothers. Meanwhile, Matt and Gary need to cut the worst player on their basketball team, Jack.
Annie reinstates Family Night in an attempt to bond with the girls. Problems arise when the teens try to escape, Nikki learns Gary is dating and Jack shocks Annie by showing up with a hot date of his own.